Homes for Sale in Pleasant Plains

Pleasant Plains is a peaceful, residential neighborhood on Staten Island's South Shore, offering a mix of detached homes and newer developments. The area is known for its family-oriented atmosphere, local schools, and proximity to the Pleasant Plains train station, enhancing connectivity. The nearby Lemon Creek Park adds a touch of natural beauty and outdoor recreation opportunities.

It's bordered by Amboy Road to the north, the Korean War Veterans Parkway to the east, and extends southward to the Raritan Bay.

The neighborhood falls under the zip code 10309.

Bedford-Stuyvesant by Price & Property Type

Pleasant Plains

Bordering Neighborhoods

The neighborhood of Pleasant Plains is bordered by the following neighborhoods:

• North: Huguenot / Prince's Bay
• East: Tottenville
• South: Atlantic Ocean
• West: Charleston / Richmond Valley

Housing Stock

Pleasant Plains in Staten Island features a suburban landscape with an array of home types, from traditional single-family homes to more expansive estates and new constructions. This quiet neighborhood is appealing for its open spaces and proximity to the coastline. Housing prices in Pleasant Plains range from around $450,000 for smaller homes to upwards of $1 million for larger properties or those with unique amenities.

Culinary

Pleasant Plains offers a mix of dining options, including casual American eateries, Italian restaurants, and seafood spots.

• Lobster House Joe's – Amboy Rd - Casual seafood restaurant specializing in lobster dishes.
• Nonna's Pizzeria & Restaurant – Amboy Rd - A local pizzeria serving classic New York-style pizza and Italian dishes.
• Page Plaza Diner – Page Ave - A traditional diner with a broad menu serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

Green Spaces

• Bloomingdale Park: Situated at Lenevar Avenue, offering large green spaces, playgrounds, and walking trails.
• Lemon Creek Park: Featuring a marina, fishing pier, and natural areas, ideal for outdoor enthusiasts and nature lovers.

Is Pleasant Plains for you?

Pleasant Plains offers a serene residential setting with the benefits of spacious homes and excellent schools, ideal for families looking for a peaceful community. The neighborhood's charm is enhanced by its proximity to natural preserves and beaches, providing a perfect blend of comfort and outdoor activities.

Pleasant Plains Real Estate Agents

Thinking of buying a home in Pleasant Plains? Our Pleasant Plains realtors are neighborhood experts who can help you find your dream home. In addition to a continuous feed of listings from all four of the MLSs covering New York City, we can provide up-to-the-minute Pleasant Plains real estate information such as average home prices and house sales history so that you can make a well-informed decision.

If you're selling a home in the Pleasant Plains area, our listing agents will provide current market data for home values, comparison properties (comps), and a highly-tailored marketing plan to make sure you get the best price for your home.