Homes for Sale in Prince's Bay

Prince's Bay, a picturesque neighborhood on Staten Island's South Shore, is renowned for its historic homes, large properties, and beautiful natural settings, including the Lemon Creek Park. The area offers a serene, suburban lifestyle with a maritime heritage, evidenced by the Prince's Bay Lighthouse. Residents value the neighborhood's tranquility, spaciousness, and scenic waterfront.

The area is framed by Hylan Boulevard to the east, Pleasant Plains to the north, and stretches along the Raritan Bay shoreline to the south.

Prince's Bay is primarily within the zip code 10309.

Bedford-Stuyvesant by Price & Property Type

Prince's Bay

Bordering Neighborhoods

The neighborhood of Prince's Bay is bordered by the following neighborhoods:

• North: Huguenot
• East: Tottenville
• South: Atlantic Ocean
• West: Pleasant Plains

Housing Stock

Prince's Bay is known for its historic homes and newer luxury developments, with a significant number of properties offering waterfront access or views. It’s a neighborhood that prides itself on its nautical heritage, with a mix of older Colonials and Victorian homes alongside contemporary custom builds. Housing prices in Prince's Bay can start at $500,000 and can go well over $1 million, particularly for waterfront or larger estate homes.

Culinary

Prince's Bay features a range of dining experiences, from upscale seafood restaurants to casual cafes and pizzerias.

• Seguine Bagels – Seguine Ave - Known for its fresh bagels, sandwiches, and breakfast items.
• Toto's Restaurant – Amboy Rd - Traditional Italian-American cuisine in a family-friendly setting.
• Lemon Tree Asian Bistro – Seguine Ave - Offering a fusion of Chinese, Japanese, and Thai cuisines.

Green Spaces

• Lemon Creek Park: Known for its fishing pier and natural beauty, this park serves the Prince's Bay community with outdoor recreation.
• Wolfe's Pond Park: With its beach, playgrounds, and hiking trails, it's a popular destination for families and outdoor adventurers.

Is Prince's Bay for you?

Prince's Bay stands out for its rich history and maritime character, offering picturesque views, historic landmarks, and a peaceful residential atmosphere. This neighborhood is favored by those who appreciate a slower pace of life with the added benefit of coastal living.

Prince's Bay Real Estate Agents

Thinking of buying a home in Prince's Bay? Our Prince's Bay realtors are neighborhood experts who can help you find your dream home. In addition to a continuous feed of listings from all four of the MLSs covering New York City, we can provide up-to-the-minute Prince's Bay real estate information such as average home prices and house sales history so that you can make a well-informed decision.

If you're selling a home in the Prince's Bay area, our listing agents will provide current market data for home values, comparison properties (comps), and a highly-tailored marketing plan to make sure you get the best price for your home.