Homes for Sale in City Island

City Island, a unique maritime community in the Bronx, is reminiscent of a New England fishing village. Known for its seafood restaurants, nautical history, and small-town vibe, the island offers a distinct departure from typical New York City life. Residents and visitors enjoy boating, waterfront dining, and exploring the area's quaint shops and maritime attractions.

This small island is located in the Long Island Sound, connected to the Bronx mainland by the City Island Bridge, and is surrounded by Eastchester Bay and Long Island Sound.

City Island is within the zip code 10464.

City Island by Price & Property Type

Bordering Neighborhoods:

The neighborhood of City Island is bordered by the following neighborhoods:

• North: Long Island Sound
• East: Long Island Sound
• South: Pelham Bay Park / Eastchester Bay
• West: Pelham Bay Park

Housing Stock:

City Island is a nautical community offering a mix of Victorian homes, Cape Cod-style houses, and waterfront properties. Known for its marinas and seafood restaurants, the island provides a small-town feel. Housing prices here can range from $400,000 for a small cottage to over $1 million for a waterfront property.

Culinary:

City Island is famous for its seafood restaurants, offering waterfront dining with views of the Long Island Sound.

• The Black Whale – City Island Ave - Cozy seafood restaurant with a variety of dishes.
• Johnny's Reef Restaurant – City Island Ave - A waterfront seafood spot with a casual, cafeteria-style setup.
• Sammy's Fish Box – City Island Ave - Known for its generous portions and wide selection of seafood.

Green Spaces:

City Island, a nautical community, offers waterfront parks and marinas:

• Pelham Bay Park: The largest park in New York City, located near City Island, offers beaches, trails, and golf courses.
• City Island Park: A small park with views of the Long Island Sound, offering a playground and picnic areas. Located at City Island Ave & Fordham St.

Is City Island for you?

City Island's unique maritime character and seafood restaurants provide a small-town atmosphere within New York City. The scenic views and boating opportunities make it a desirable location for those seeking a peaceful, water-adjacent lifestyle.

City Island Real Estate Agents

Thinking of buying a home in City Island? Our City Island realtors are neighborhood experts who can help you find your dream home. In addition to a continuous feed of listings from all four of the MLSs covering New York City, we can provide up-to-the-minute City Island real estate information such average home prices and house sales history so that you can make a well-informed decision.

If you're selling a home in the City Island area, our listing agents will provide current market data for home values, comparison properties (comps), and a highly-tailored marketing plan to make sure you get the best price for your home.