Homes for Sale in Tottenville

Tottenville, located at the southern tip of Staten Island, boasts a combination of historic homes and modern luxury properties, with some waterfront estates. The neighborhood is known for its old-world charm, with a mix of Victorian, Colonial, and custom-built houses. Housing prices in Tottenville vary greatly, with some historic homes starting around $400,000 and luxury, waterfront properties reaching several million dollars.

The neighborhood of Tottenville is bordered by the following neighborhoods: North: Pleasant Plains / Prince's Bay, East: Richmond Valley / Charleston, South: Atlantic Ocean, West: Huguenot.

Tottenville features upscale dining and casual eateries, with a focus on Italian, seafood, and American cuisines. Notable spots include Angelina's Ristorante, Ruddy & Dean, and The Tottenville Tavern.

Green spaces are a highlight, with Conference House Park and Tottenville Shore Park offering beautiful shoreline views and outdoor activities.

Tottenville is an ideal neighborhood for those seeking a quiet, historic area with a strong sense of local heritage, offering residents historic charm, a tight-knit community, and beaches with views of the Raritan Bay.

Bedford-Stuyvesant by Price & Property Type

Tottenville

Bordering Neighborhoods

The neighborhood of Tottenville is bordered by the following neighborhoods:

• North: Pleasant Plains / Prince's Bay
• East: Richmond Valley / Charleston
• South: Atlantic Ocean
• West: Huguenot

Housing Stock

Tottenville, located at the southern tip of Staten Island, boasts a combination of historic homes and modern luxury properties, with some waterfront estates. The neighborhood is known for its old-world charm, with a mix of Victorian, Colonial, and custom-built houses. Housing prices in Tottenville vary greatly, with some historic homes starting around $400,000 and luxury, waterfront properties reaching several million dollars.

Culinary

Tottenville features upscale dining and casual eateries, with a focus on Italian, seafood, and American cuisines.

• Angelina's Ristorante – Ellis St - Fine Italian dining set in an elegant Victorian home.
• Ruddy & Dean – Amboy Rd - A steakhouse offering a selection of prime meats and seafood dishes.
• The Tottenville Tavern – Amboy Rd - A local tavern known for its pub fare and friendly atmosphere.

Green Spaces

• Conference House Park: Known for its historic significance and beautiful shoreline, offering walking paths and panoramic views.
• Tottenville Shore Park: A waterfront park with beach access, walking paths, and views of the Raritan Bay.

Is Tottenville for you?

Tottenville is at the southernmost point of Staten Island and New York City, offering residents historic charm, a tight-knit community, and beaches with views of the Raritan Bay. It's an ideal neighborhood for those seeking a quiet, historic area with a strong sense of local heritage.

Tottenville Real Estate Agents

Thinking of buying a home in Tottenville? Our Tottenville realtors are neighborhood experts who can help you find your dream home. In addition to a continuous feed of listings from all four of the MLSs covering New York City, we can provide up-to-the-minute Tottenville real estate information such average home prices and house sales history so that you can make a well-informed decision.

If you're selling a home in the Tottenville area, our listing agents will provide current market data for home values, comparison properties (comps), and a highly-tailored marketing plan to make sure you get the best price for your home.